Make this creamy, keto-friendly Ninja Creami ice cream with just 6 easy steps! This roundup features the top high-protein, low-carb recipes from trusted food blogs to help you stay on track while enjoying dessert.
There’s something magical about turning simple, low-carb ingredients into a rich, creamy frozen treat. If you’re on a keto diet and love your Ninja Creami, you’re in for a real treat! In this post, we’ve curated the best Ninja Creami keto ice cream recipes using cottage cheese, berries, nut butters, and more — all inspired by the highest-ranking food blogs.
Whether you’re craving raspberry cottage cheese ice cream or a protein-packed peanut butter swirl, these easy recipes are perfect for warm-weather indulgence without the guilt. Grab your Ninja Creami and get ready to spin up some frozen keto magic!
🍨 6 Best Ninja Creami Keto Ice Cream Recipes You’ll Love
🍜 1. Keto Raspberry Cottage Cheese Ice Cream – My Life Cookbook
Flavor Summary: A tangy, refreshing blend of fresh raspberries and creamy cottage cheese, topped with optional crunchy pecans for cheesecake vibes.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Blend cottage cheese until smooth
- Add raspberries and sweetener, blend again
- Spoon into container and optionally top with nut crumble
- Freeze 1–2 hrs until scoopable
- Enjoy or add mix-ins
Time: ~2 hours
Tags: Keto, High Protein, Low Carb
Recipe Credit: My Life Cookbook
💡 Tip: Freeze for 1 hour then check texture every 30 min for your perfect softness.
👉 Check full recipe
🍜 2. Ninja Creami Keto Raspberry Cottage Cheese Ice Cream – SaraTasty
Flavor Summary: Creamy and protein-packed, with sweet‑tart raspberries and a smooth cottage cheese base—guilt-free dessert bliss.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Blend cottage cheese until smooth
- Add raspberries and sweetener, blend again
- (Optional) Make pecan topping on skillet
- Freeze 24 hrs in Ninja Creami pint
- Spin, respin, top with crunch
Time: ~4 hrs (plus freeze)
Tags: Keto, Gluten‑Free, Protein
Recipe Credit: SaraTasty
💡 Tip: Use full‑fat cottage cheese like Good Culture for optimal creaminess.
👉 Check full recipe
🍜 3. Cottage Cheese Ice Cream (Chocolate) – The Balanced Nutritionist
Flavor Summary: Decadent chocolate flavor meets high-protein cottage cheese base, textured like frozen custard yet guilt-free.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Blend cottage cheese, pudding mix, cocoa powder
- Freeze in Creami pint for 24 hrs
- Spin on ice cream setting
- Respin for smoother texture
- Add mix‑ins (e.g., chips, nuts)
Time: ~24 hrs
Tags: Chocolate, High Protein
Recipe Credit: The Balanced Nutritionist
💡 Tip: Use sugar‑free pudding mix for a low‑carb treat.
👉 Check full recipe
🍜 4. Cottage Cheese Ninja Creami (Vanilla) – FoodBanjo
Flavor Summary: Simple yet satisfying vanilla base—protein-rich and customizable for endless flavor possibilities.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Combine cottage cheese, milk, vanilla, sweetener
- Freeze 24 hrs in Creami pint
- Process on ice cream mode; add milk if crumbly
- Re-spin for creaminess
- Customize with mix‑ins like chips or cookies
Time: ~24 hrs
Tags: Vanilla, Versatile, Protein
Recipe Credit: FoodBanjo
💡 Tip: Use a splash of milk during Re‑spin to smooth texture.
👉 Check full recipe
🍜 5. Ninja Creami Cottage Cheese Ice Cream – iDreamofIceCream
Flavor Summary: Smooth, protein-packed, and tart-fresh thanks to pudding mix and cottage cheese—the base you didn’t know you needed.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Mix milk, pudding mix, vanilla, sugar
- Stir in cottage cheese
- Freeze 24 hrs
- Spin, respin if crumbly (add 1 Tbsp milk)
- Add mix‑ins with Mix‑In setting
Time: ~24 hrs
Tags: Protein, Pudding‑Infused
Recipe Credit: iDreamofIceCream
💡 Tip: Opt for small-curd cottage cheese to avoid pre-blending.
👉 Check full recipe
🍜 6. Strawberry Cottage Cheese Ice Cream – NutritionToFit
Flavor Summary: Tastes like strawberry cheesecake—vibrant berries blended into a protein-rich cottage cheese base for creamy satisfaction.
Quick 5‑Step Summary:
- Add cottage cheese, strawberries, honey, vanilla to Creami pint
- Puree smooth with immersion blender
- Freeze 24 hrs
- Spin on Lite Ice Cream, then Re‑spin
- Add mix‑ins and serve
Time: ~24 hrs
Tags: Strawberry, Cheesecake‑Style, High Protein
Recipe Credit: NutritionToFit
💡 Tip: Use 1–2% cottage cheese; otherwise add milk before Re‑spin.
👉 Check full recipe
❓ FAQ: Ninja Creami Keto Ice Cream Tips & Troubleshooting
Can I use frozen fruit in Ninja Creami keto recipes?
Yes! Frozen berries like raspberries or strawberries work great and keep the carb count low. Just be sure to blend them well with your base before freezing for even texture and flavor.
Does cottage cheese really make good ice cream?
Absolutely! When blended, cottage cheese becomes ultra-creamy and adds a rich, cheesecake-like texture. It’s also high in protein and works surprisingly well in keto frozen desserts.
What protein powder works best for Ninja Creami recipes?
Whey isolate or casein protein powders work best for creamy consistency. Make sure it’s low in carbs and has no added sugars to keep your dessert keto-friendly.
How long should I freeze the mixture before spinning?
The standard is 24 hours for the Ninja Creami to spin properly. For quicker versions, freeze for at least 4–6 hours, but note the texture may be softer and may require extra respins.
Can I make Ninja Creami keto ice cream without protein powder?
Yes! Most recipes using cottage cheese already offer plenty of protein. You can skip the powder or substitute with collagen peptides for a cleaner ingredient list.
What’s the best way to avoid icy texture?
Use full-fat ingredients and avoid too much water-based fruit. Adding a splash of unsweetened almond milk or cream before a Re-spin can help smooth out the ice crystals.
Are all cottage cheese brands keto-friendly?
Not all. Choose full-fat, no-added-sugar cottage cheese. Brands like Good Culture or Daisy tend to be keto-approved and have a smoother texture.
💬 Conclusion
There’s nothing quite like a creamy, cold dessert on a warm day — especially when it fits your keto lifestyle. These 6 Ninja Creami keto ice cream recipes prove that you don’t have to sacrifice flavor or texture to stay on track. From fruity favorites like raspberry and strawberry to indulgent chocolate and peanut butter, each recipe offers a delicious, high-protein treat that’s easy to make and even easier to love.
We’d love to hear from you!
💬 Which flavor will you try first?
📌 Save this post on Pinterest to keep your keto dessert inspiration close at hand.
👩🍳 Share with fellow Ninja Creami fans who want to enjoy sweet treats without the sugar crash!
Happy spinning and sweet (low-carb) scooping! 🍨💕